Maine State Police under fire for disregarding video confession of man soliciting minors for sex

The Maine State Police have faced criticism following their handling of a disturbing case involving a confessed child predator. Despite admitting to real-life victims and attempting to solicit sex from a 13-year-old decoy, a confession video was initially overlooked. The predator was apprehended thanks to the efforts of a civilian group called “Predator Poachers”, who orchestrated a successful sting operation capturing a detailed confession. 

Initially, Maine State Police declined to review the evidence, prompting the group to share the nearly three-hour-long video on X, formerly known as Twitter. Within three hours of its posting, the Maine State Police released a statement addressing the incident. 

“The Maine State Police and the Computer Crimes Unit Task Force is aware of several groups nationwide that conduct their own private investigations into child exploitation. It is our understanding and experience that the tactics that are employed by these groups are at best questionable and at worst coercive.” The statement later added, "A joint independent and proper investigation into this alleged child exploitation is underway by law enforcement at this time to ensure the rights of all involved.”

The confession video, shared via an X account operated by Predator Poachers' Alex Rosen, revealed disturbing details. The predator confessed to viewing, downloading, and trading child exploitation materials involving children as young as one year old. When questioned about the extent of such materials on their mobile phone, the predator admitted to possessing approximately twenty videos. The chilling conversation shed light on the heinous nature of the crimes, with the predator admitting to the exploitation of vulnerable children.

Rosen: “Let’s talk about what’s happening on Telegram.”

Rosen: “What’s happening to the babies in these files or videos.”

Predator: “They’re getting touched.”

Rosen: “Who’s usually doing the touching?”

Predator: Dad, or mom, or a sibling.”

The delayed response by the Maine State Police to the predator's confession video prompts reflection on the role of social media in combating child exploitation. While platforms like social media empower civilian groups to expose predatory behavior, recent events in Maine suggest a preference for collaboration with established agencies like Homeland Security Investigations. This preference may inadvertently discourage public reporting of abuse incidents, further eroding trust in the effectiveness of the Maine State Police. The incident involving Predator Poachers underscores the agency's hesitancy to take action, exacerbating public skepticism and undermining confidence in how cyber tips are handled.

These shortcomings emphasize the urgent need for improved training and resources for law enforcement agencies to combat child exploitation and abuse. Civilian teams often provide concise and well-documented tips, highlighting the potential value of collaboration between authorities and such groups. Maine State Police have announced intentions to investigate whether Predator Poachers violated the rights of the predator.

In 2014, former Maine State Police Chief, Andrew Demers, 74, was accused of sexually assaulting a 4-year-old female relative. Although State police initially received the tip on March 10, they instead referred the case to the district attorney who moved the case over to the sheriff’s office to investigate. According to Central Maine, the case stood unresolved for several months, with the sheriff’s office failing to get a written confession even after Demers admitted to assaulting the child. Demers was out on a $5000 cash bail until a Cumberland County judge sentenced him to 5 years in prison for unlawful sexual contact under a plea deal. His last year was suspended. 

In 2023, Andrew Belisle, 71, a longtime member of law enforcement in Cumberland County, was indicted on charges of sexually abusing a 14-year-old child. Belisle is out of custody on his own personal recognizance. 

The handling of child sexual abuse cases by the Maine State Police has been marred by controversies over the years, leading to a significant erosion of public trust. Addressing these issues will require measures aimed at enhancing transparency, accountability, and officer training. Collaboration with civilian groups like Predator Poachers could be part of the solution.

In an interview by the Maine Wire, Rosen emphasized his group’s commitment to adhere to relevant statutes to ensure law enforcement can effectively utilize the information obtained from suspected predators.

According to a 2023 legislative report by the Maine State Police, the child exploitation task force has seen a staggering 344 percent increase in internet-related child exploitation tips. The report highlights the pressing need for improved triage and prioritization of these tips. The report was written in opposition to LD 1576 and LD 1056 which expands requirements for obtaining warrants for all electronic devices. According to Spectrum Local News, the bills “prohibit local and state governments from helping a federal agency collect electronic information unless a person consents, they have a warrant or it meets a legally recognized exception, such as an emergency”. 

Predator Poachers, a Houston-based civilian group founded by Alex Rosen, conducts sting operations targeting adults seeking sexual activities with minors. Their investigative efforts have led to arrests across 44 US states. The group's strategy involves creating aliases using social media accounts, engaging with potential predators, and facilitating real-life meetings to expose their intentions.

Predator Poachers mirrors the concept of Chris Hansen's "To Catch a Predator," a television program that conducted sting operations on adult men seeking minors for sexual activities. Law enforcement credited the show with deterring potential predators from engaging in real-life meetups with children.